Composite Toe vs Steel Toe: What’s Better?
Before we dive into the two commonly used toe cap types, we recommend that you check with your employer to ensure you are getting the right kind of footwear for the job. In case you work independently or want something for your DIY projects, we believe this blog post will fill you in to make the right decision.
The History of Toe Caps
Steel toe caps have been used in safety footwear for a long time. In fact, it was at the start of the 20th Century when using safety footwear became recognised. This was the time when liability costs started piling up and with the implementation of laws regarding compensations for injured workforce, a real focus was put on safety at work. This is why the compulsory safety standards have allowed such industries and workplaces to become safer.
Fun fact: The first safety footwear was called ‘Sabot’ and featured a wooden frame. In fact, the word ‘sabotage’ is believed to come from the name of safety shoes when workers would wreck machinery with their sabots!
With the introduction of steel toe cap shoes in the 1940s, things got much better for the workers and the business owners, as these shoes were tough and durable and offered superior protection. While composite toe caps are relatively new, they have gained a lot of popularity. So, are they really better than steel-toe cap trainers and boots?
Composite Toe Caps
The weight and comfort of the toe-capped boots are important factors for many people when deciding on the right safety footwear. Here’s the good news - not only are composite toe caps lighter than steel, but they also offer the same level of durability, if not better. While the actual material of composite toe boots can vary from supplier to supplier, it is commonly made from fiberglass, carbon fibre, Kevlar, and plastic.
The main reason why composite toe caps are lighter comes done to how they are produced. The nanotechnology used to make composite toe caps creates thin layers of fibre that are then fused together, creating a strong yet thin cap. Below are some other benefits and features of composite toe caps.
Unlike their steel counterparts, composite toe caps don’t get too hot or cold, as they are non-conductive. They neither conduct heat nor cold, meaning they are perfect for insulated boots.
Don’t Set Off Metal Detectors
If you are someone who has to pass through security scanners on a regular basis, composite toe caps can be a great time saver. You won’t set off any alarms every time you pass the scanners.
Perfect for Safety Trainers
Since safety trainers have a more sporty profile, composite toe caps are great for them. The lightweight composite material will keep the trainers looking slick and easy to maneuver.
Ideal for Electricians
Composite toe caps are good for working in hazardous electrical environments because they don’t conduct electricity.
Steel Toe Caps
Alright, so you must be wondering, “Looks like steel toe caps are no match for composite toe caps,” but hold your horses!
Steel toe caps continue to be the most popular option in the market for safety shoes and boots. Thanks to the new advancements, they are not as heavy as they used to be. Have a look at our lightweight safety trainers with steel toe caps. Because they have been around for the best part of a century, we are confident that they’ll be around for long, especially because of the industry-wide trust and reliability among operatives and workers. A common myth that they could cut off and crush your toes has also been debunked by professionals, stating that it would require extraordinary circumstances, and even then, it would just crush your toes and not amputate you. Moreover, here are some benefits and features of steel-toe cap boots and trainers.
Steel toe cap is generally cheaper than composite toe caps, thanks to the established technology that’s commonly available around the globe.
Steel toe caps are usually as strong, and in some cases, even stronger than composite toe caps.
According to many industries and professionals, steel toe caps remain the market leaders because they are tried and tested for decades. There is more trust in the consistent performance of this material.
More Styles, More Sizes, More Shapes
Since composite toe caps are a recent introduction, they still seem to be used in safety boots and safety trainers with higher specifications and for specialist industries. Naturally, this means that steel-toe cap boots and trainers are available in more styles, sizes, and shapes.
When making a decision on which one to go for, it’s worth keeping in mind that both, composite and steel toe caps have been subjected to and met necessary standards. So, no matter which option you choose, you can rest assured that they are both fully compliant with a set of standards.
Overall, with composite toe caps, you get the same benefits as steel toe caps, and a little more, such as resistance to the conductivity of cold, heat, and electricity. However, there might be more limitations in terms of designs and sizes. If you are on a tighter budget, then going for steel toe caps will usually be a better option. Whichever way you go, you should be fine.